Coral Gables Mayor Vince Lago said on Tuesday that he didn’t have to recuse himself from a vote on a variance appeal because he doesn’t do business with Brian Goldmeier anymore. Which raises an interesting question: Since when?
The controversy centered on an appeal involving property at 722 Aledo Avenue, owned by political fundraiser and consultant Brian Goldmeier, one of Lago’s longest-running political allies and a man who has spent years helping elect candidates throughout South Florida raise the money they need to get elected.
Before the vote, a resident named Samantha Gasta, or something like that, argued that Lago should recuse himself because of his relationship with Goldmeier and his constant gloating about transparency. And Ladra thinks she thought way too much of the mayor’s good will.
Read related: Vince Lago’s political war erupted in a public battle at Tuesday’s meeting
“Mr. Mayor, you have always been a strong advocate for government transparency and I applaud that. You also lobbied strongly for an inspector
general for our city, which I supported as well, requires that you remain consistently with your public statements.”
She must be new here.
This speaker mentioned that Goldmeier had made almost $250,000 — a quarter of million dollars — for work on his political campaigns just since 2024.
“Both of you have been extremely successful,” she said. “Of course, there is nothing illegal about having a successful business relationship. And both of you should be commended on jobs well done.
“However, it does cause the everyday resident to question whether you can impartially evaluate Mr. Goldmeier’s appeal today. As much as an individual can try to remain objective, it is extremely difficult for someone to evaluate a case like this one and not have such a strong and long-standing relationship impact their decision-making, even if its subconscious.
“Therefore Mr. Mayor I ask that you show our city that you truly are about government transparency. I ask you to do what is right and recuse yourself on the appeal.”
She seemed so hopeful.
Read related: What transparency? 22 reasons NOT to vote for Coral Gables Mayor Vince Lago
Before going on to another speaker, the mayor, por supuesto, had to address this seeming obvious conflict of interest. He said he had asked the city attorney for an opinion on the matter and asked her to give a quick synopsis.
“Based on the facts that you provided, that you previously had a contactually relationship, you were in a contractual agreement with an entity that
is owned by Mr. Goldmeier,” City Attorney Cristina Suarez said, stopping to clear her throat several times during her explanation. Like something was stuck in it. Like a little piece of the garbage she was spewing.
“You advised that that contract has concluded and that you currently have no contractual agreements or no business with Mr. Goldmeier or any entity that he is associated with,” Suarez continued, looking uncomfortable anyway. “So, based on those facts, there’s no actual voting conflicts under state law, there’s no actual voting conflict under the Miami-Dade County code.
“Any suggestion that you would be enhanced by this action is remote or speculative,” the city attorney said.
Well call Ladra speculative!
Suarez also said that she often reminds the commissioners that on these “quasi-judicial” matters, they can only vote if they can be impartial.
“That was the advice that I gave you, that if you can remain fair and impartial then you can proceed,” she said, sort of like saying that she was going off of his information.
Lago just said, “I do not have a bias on this matter and I will not be recusing myself.” And he knew he couldn’t because his buddy wouldn’t have won the appeal without his swing vote. It was a 3-2 to approve the appeal without the conditions set by the code enforcement board.
But it makes Ladra wonder if all of the extensive renovations Goldmeier did on his property were permitted and if any other variances were sought (more on that later).
Read related: Mayor Vince Lago’s consultant files complaint vs Coral Gables recall activist
Someone on behalf of an anonymous group of Gables residents had already hand-delivered a package to City Attorney Suarez days earlier, complete with campaign finance records, corporate filings, social media posts and photographs intended to demonstrate what nobody in Coral Gables politics seriously disputes: Lago and Goldmeier have been political partners for years.
Goldmeier’s company, BYG Strategies, has provided consulting services to Lago campaigns and Lago’s political committee. Campaign reports show
money flowing from Lago’s political operation to Goldmeier’s firm. More than $53,000 from his political action committee, Gables First, for the 2025 election. That’s just last year. So Goldmeier, who is famously part of “Team Lago” and has been associated with him since at least 2021, doesn’t have a contract now? Will he when qualifying for the next election starts and ends next week?
Photos show the two together on the campaign trail. Social media posts place them in the same political orbit. Goldmeier accompanied Lago the the Formula One races.
In other words, this wasn’t exactly a case built on conspiracy theories and grainy surveillance footage. The relationship is well documented.
But Lago wasn’t buying the conflict argument. The mayor’s argument, that he no longer has a business relationship with Goldmeier, is interesting. Because that answer may have raised more questions than it resolved. No longer? When did the relationship end? Last month? Last year? Last election cycle? Five minutes before the meeting?
The distinction matters.
Nobody is saying that Lago secretly owns part of Goldmeier’s house. Though the argument could be said that he helped Brian buy it. The concern is whether a mayor should be voting on a matter affecting a longtime political consultant who has pretty much helped put him where he is.
The recusal request relied heavily on Miami-Dade ethics provisions that prohibit elected officials from voting on matters involving certain business relationships. Whether that standard legally applies here is ultimately an ethics question.
But the appearance question is much easier.
Read related: New Coral Gables Mayor Vince Lago has ‘friends’ in all the wrong places
If a political consultant has helped elect you, raised money for you, advised your campaigns and profited from your political operation, should you
be voting on a matter directly affecting his property? Reasonable people can disagree.
What is harder to understand is why city leaders so often treat recusal as some sort of admission of guilt.
Recusal is not a confession. It’s like a seatbelt. Nobody assumes you caused the accident because you’re wearing one. The purpose is to avoid even the appearance that personal relationships influenced a public decision.
Instead, politicians frequently fight recusal requests with the intensity of someone defending a murder charge.
Which brings us back to Goldmeier.
Around Coral Gables political circles, Goldmeier is not merely another resident. He’s one of the most active political operatives in the county, the guy campaigns call when they need money raised, donors contacted and political problems solved. Think of him as the collection agent of South Florida politics.
Only instead of collecting debts, he’s collecting checks.
Lots of them.
But this story probably isn’t over.
Because Lago’s explanation wasn’t that there was never a business relationship. His explanation was that there isn’t one now.
Which means the next obvious question is whether Coral Gables residents — and perhaps ethics officials — are satisfied with that distinction.
Or whether they think the relationship is simply between campaigns.
The letter, which is 38 pages when you include all the exhibits, was also sent to Deputy City Attorney Stephanie M. Throckmorton, and Gustavo J. Ceballos, assistant city attorney and city prosecutor.
Maybe they also should have sent copies to the State Attorney’s Office and the Inspector General.
This kind of independent, government watchdog reporting is crucial to transparency and democracy. And more so every day. Help shine a light on the darker corners of our community with a contribution to Political Cortadito. Click here. Ladra thanks you for your support.
